A new competitor in prediction markets, and their brilliant case study
September 28th, 2009If you're new here, you may want to get Mercury's Blog by Email or subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
I recently found out about a new competitor in corporate prediction markets: CrowdClarity.
I’m a little partial to these guys, mainly because they come from my alma mater, the University of Michigan. The key people look to be a mix of entrepreneurial students and professionals. The company itself was started a year and a half ago, but has had success with early pilot projects.
In fact, three slides included in their “Learn more” online slideshow are quite powerful statements as to why prediction markets can be useful. They were predicting car sales in the winter of 2008/2009, during what was one of the most volatile months the industry has seen in many, many years. And the prediction market beat the internal forecast made at the beginning of the month, and the expert forecast made at the end of the month.
To recap, the prediction market beat the official GM forecast (made at the beginning of the month) easily, which isn’t hugely surprising considering the myopic nature of internal forecasting. But the prediction market also beat the Edmunds.com forecast. This is particularly interesting, as Edmunds would have had the opportunity to review almost the entire month’s news and data before making their forecast at the end of the month.
Examining the numbers
Let’s quickly quantify this error. Assume an average Chevrolet sells for $18,000. After dealer markup, assume that GM/Chevrolet receives $16,000 per vehicle.
Within the first week of November 2008, the prediction market would have warned Chevrolet that they were going to miss their revenue targets by $800 million in the Chevrolet division alone. And depending upon the exact product mix, this could have easily exceeded $1billion.
Now Chris can blather on about corporate prediction markets, but he’s simply wrong. Assume that even with three weeks’ early warning Chevrolet was only able to save 10% of that gap, it’s still $80million in savings. Even if a corporate prediction market for a giant company like GM cost $200,000 a year, that would still be a return on investment of 40,000 %. And again, that’s in the Chevrolet division alone. (Note: It would be a rare prediction market that cost $200k/year to run.)
Now not every problem should be solved by a prediction market. This is where management expertise comes in: are the errors large enough to warrant the cost of reducing those errors? But big problems with big numbers are often very suitable to address with a prediction market.
Summary
I’d like to wish good luck to the CrowdClarity team. It’s great to see Wolverine entrepreneurs working on prediction markets. There are more and more players each year in the corporate prediction market scene, but with case studies like this behind their belts, they’ll be well-placed to pick up some business.
